Book Review: The Martian by Weir (4 stars)

The Martian by Andy Weir

4 out of 5 stars

Read in February 2014

“Mars keeps trying to kill me. . . .  Mars and my stupidity keep trying to kill me.”

Totally awesome! Think Michener’s Space with a full orchestral treatment of “I’d like to Teach the World to Sing” as theme music.

Nail-biting suspense on top of solid, hard science. With more than a dash of humor. Really, really good storytelling. The best hard SF I’ve read in years.

Quibbles? Sure, but none which materially affected the story, with the possible exception of the drama-enhancing gaps in imagination and communications. In fact, what threw me out of the tale most–and most often–was the gratuitous profanity. Yeah, I know, soldiers and sailors (and presumably, astronauts) cuss a lot. But it’s too simplistic to load the script down with profanity. It wasn’t necessary, and it showed laziness. Weir did such a fine job of making his cast real and individual that it detracted.

Nice cover art.

“Live Another Sol”

October 4, 2015 Addendum:

Mr. Weir could learn something from Hollywood, specifically Ridley Scott. The Martian movie handled the profanity much better. The viewer has no doubt that Mark Watney had strong emotions and expressed them strongly without being assaulting by it.


1 thought on “Book Review: The Martian by Weir (4 stars)

  1. Reblogged this on Misty Midwest Mossiness and commented:

    My uncle posted a review of a recently released hard science fiction novel as his second blog post on his new blog. I supplied some technical assistance, but the content and publication are all his. Stop by and wish him well in his new electronic frontier adventure.

Comments are closed.